Turkey’s street protests get personal
(AP) – Brash and stubborn, Turkey’s leader doesn’t shrink from a scrap. His voice booms when he gets on a podium and his folksy zingers enthrall supporters as much as they repulse opponents. That trademark combativeness, though, is fueling the protests against his government.
Turkey has been gripped by street skirmishes since Friday, when a police raid against a peaceful demonstration in an Istanbul park blew the lid off pent-up hostility toward the government in a divided population. The protests are largely driven by visceral dislike among urban and secular circles for Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the three-term prime minister with designs on the presidency.
They see him as an increasingly uncompromising figure who has been backsliding on his stated commitment to individual freedoms and an early record of democratic reforms.
The backdrop is a patchwork of tension between overlapping strands of the modern and traditional, the secular and religious, the democratic and authoritarian, military and civilian. Under Erdogan’s firm grasp over the last decade, Turkey moved toward electoral and economic stability, earning a reputation as a regional success story and a possible model for countries struggling to reconcile Islam and democratic impulses.
The protests make clear that many Turks — but hardly all — think his hardheaded style, which served its purpose early on for a country cowed by the military, has run its course.
Conciliatory comments toward the protesters from some government officials also hint at disagreement with their leader’s approach.
Since Turkey has a stable developing democracy and Erdogan’s Islamic-rooted government doesn’t appear to be in danger of toppling before his term is up, it’s up to the prime minister to chart the course of the crisis. Although his deputy has apologized for the crackdown, Erdogan has so far doubled down, choosing confrontation over reconciliation, dismissing the demonstrators as rabble and even branding Twitter, used by activists to organize and update each other, as a menace.
“Social media is the pain in the neck of all societies,” Erdogan said.
The startling remark, hostile to a medium that much of the world has embraced, recalls other conflicts where anti-government activists relied on social media to organize. But NATO ally Turkey does not share the same dynamics as Tunisia, Egypt, or Libya, and its relative stability suggests a Mideast-style revolution is not likely to happen.
Erdogan has led his ruling party to a string of electoral landslides, buoyed by a loyal, well-organized base that has trounced the fractured political opposition. However, his own president, Abdullah Gul, has pointed out that democracy does not only work at the ballot box, a reference to the right to peaceful protest. Government opponents complain of unilateral decision-making and edicts that appear to be religiously motivated and pose a challenge to Turkey’s secular principles.
Protesters vent their displeasure by calling the 59-year-old prime minister, an ex-football player from a poor neighborhood of Istanbul, “Tayyip,” a way of denigrating Erdogan because of his paternal demeanor, which would ordinarily command respect. A traditional term of address would be “Basbakanim,” which means “My Prime Minister.”
“Tayyip, winter is coming,” warned one piece of protest graffiti. “Tayyip, would you like three kids like us?” read a sign held by a protester who lampooned Erdogan’s calls for families to have three children.
Beril Eski, a 27-year-old editor at a television station, was not inclined to protest in the past. But she joined the demonstrations that have swept Istanbul because she felt insulted by police treatment of demonstrators and what she described as an overbearing government led by a man given to provocative rhetoric.
“If he said he was sorry — I’m not sure he’s going to do that — if he said he would step back, that would make us feel comfortable,” Eski said. “That would make us feel that we have a say in our future.”
She said she had had been sympathetic to his years of effort to remove the political influence of military-backed elites, which had sidelined Erdogan’s traditional constituency of religiously devout Turks in the past. But now that Erdogan’s base is in charge, she said, he has a growing sense of entitlement.
“It’s too much about his style, too much about his being the single man in control,” Eski said.
Turkey has long been guided by strongman cults. There were centuries of Ottoman imperial rulers; then Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, the national founder who imposed an unrelenting vision of secularism that benefited like-minded elites; and the military, quick to step in when unhappy with civilian leadership.
On Erdogan’s watch, the economy has grown, the military has dropped out of politics and diplomats have confidently fanned out across the region. The rapid expansion of Turkish Airlines, the national flagship, symbolizes the ambitions of a country that started to rediscover the purported glories of an Ottoman era seen as backward by Ataturk, whose image has been seen on posters and flags at the recent protests.
A product of political Islam, Erdogan reassured supporters of Western-style democracy with an early push for European Union membership. But opponents feel his government’s emphasis on “morality,” and measures such as restrictions on alcohol consumption, mask a campaign to tamper with their most intimate decisions in the name of Islam.
The prime minister was so confident in the past that national billboards have linked his legacy to plans for the centenary of the national founding in 2023. That lofty vision ties in with his ambition, now in doubt, to switch Turkey to a presidential system of government by referendum, allowing him to run for the post and possibly stay at Turkey’s helm for another decade.
“We won’t let Erdogan be defeated by anyone. Neither we, nor our voters, would allow that. He is a centenary leader. Our prime minister is the one who led the great transformation of Turkey,” Yalcin Akdogan, an aide to the prime minister, said Monday in an interview with HaberTurk television.
Erdogan seemed politically untouchable, but the street challenge reveals his vulnerability.
“I think people are excited to possibly witness a David and Goliath story,” said Arda Batu, vice chairman of the ARI Movement, a non-governmental group based in Istanbul.
He said, however, that the protesters were unlikely to defeat him even though they had inflicted an “important wound” on the country’s leader.
“It seems there is no political party to harness this energy” in the streets, Batu wrote in an email to The Associated Press. “I think that the greatest strength of this political movement, the fact that it was an independent public movement, also points to the greatest weakness in Turkish politics, the lack of strong opposition.”